Outlining vs. Discovery Writing: Which One Works for You?
Find Out if You're a Planner, a Discovery Writer, or a Bit of Both
Writers approach storytelling in different ways—some love structure, others thrive on spontaneity, and many fall somewhere in between. Take this quick quiz to find out your writing style and how to make the most of it!
Instructions:
For each question, choose the answer that best describes your approach to writing. At the end, count how many A, B, and C answers you have to see where you fit.
The Quiz: What Kind of Writer Are You?
How do you start a new writing project?
A) I outline the plot, plan my characters, and create a roadmap before writing.
B) I dive in with a rough idea and see where the story takes me.
C) I sketch out some key moments or themes but leave plenty of room for discovery.
Do you know how your book will end before you begin writing?
A) Yes, I usually have the ending mapped out early.
B) No, I figure it out as I go.
C) I have a vague idea, but it might change.
When you sit down to write, what guides you?
A) A detailed outline or scene-by-scene plan.
B) My characters and instincts—I write what feels right in the moment.
C) A mix—I have a rough plan but allow changes as I write.
How do you handle plot holes or writer’s block?
A) I go back to my outline and adjust before moving forward.
B) I write through it and see where the story naturally leads.
C) I brainstorm some options and test what works best.
Do you revise heavily after finishing your first draft?
A) Not much—my structured approach means my drafts are fairly polished.
B) A lot—since I discover the story as I go, I often need major revisions.
C) Some—I revise certain areas but usually keep the core intact.
How do you feel about writing exercises like beat sheets or three-act structure?
A) I love them! They keep my story on track.
B) I don’t use them—I prefer to let the story unfold organically.
C) I might use them as a loose guide but don’t stick to them rigidly.
What’s your biggest writing struggle?
A) I sometimes over-plan and struggle to start writing.
B) I get lost in the story and have to go back and fix plot issues.
C) Finding the right balance between structure and spontaneity.
Your Results & Tailored Writing Advice:
🔵 Mostly A’s – You’re a PlannerYou thrive on structure, preferring to know where your story is headed before you write. Outlining helps you feel confident and efficient, but be mindful of allowing room for spontaneity so your writing doesn’t feel too rigid.
✅ Top Tip: If you find yourself over-planning and struggling to start, set a limit on how much outlining you do before writing. Give yourself permission to deviate from the plan if a better idea emerges.
🟢 Mostly B’s – You’re a Discovery WriterYou enjoy the excitement of uncovering the story as you write. This method keeps your writing fresh and surprising, but it may mean extra revision later. Consider adding some light planning to help avoid major rewrites.
✅ Top Tip: Being a Discovery Writer (sometimes called a Pantser) is an exciting and creative way to write—you let the story unfold naturally, often surprising even yourself. One thing to keep in mind is that your second draft will involve more shaping and refining, so don’t stress about editing as you go or if your word count feels short. The first draft is about exploration; the second draft is where you tighten the plot, deepen character arcs, and fill in any gaps..
🟡 Mostly C’s – You’re a Bit of BothYou like a balance between planning and discovery, using outlines as a guide rather than a rulebook. This flexibility can be a great strength, allowing structure while keeping creativity alive.
✅ Top Tip: Pay attention to when you feel most stuck—are you too tied to an outline, or is your lack of structure making the story meander? Adjust accordingly. A midpoint check-in, where you reassess your plan, can help keep you on track.
Kommentare